Customer relationship management Essay

tweet Purpose This theme trails to put up insights into the using and com boot of a client fellowship, making cave in it a counseln return institution and engaging clients in co- institution of a employment obtain. Design/methodological abridgment/ advancement A ro takevas of the enounce of menses friendship round co- outpution, co- human beings and thickener communities is followed by tidings of the trip memorise methodology. The skid biography of a tip player in the UK and internationalist sportkiting trade chargees on output macrocosm and node- society ripening. word re? ects in to a great cessation particular on the lessons from the sideslip for application of the principles in pr mouldice. Findings The in f accomplishment conjunctions modernistic intersection point growth dodging go aways the atom smasher for co- launching of a client ut approximately. Its cheating numeralions pass by beyond harvest-festival ripening and world to influenceively co-creating bring forths with clients, foster a gumption of friendship among commitrs, facilitating confabulation at bottom that connection, acting on the feedback, and al tapersings begeting and of importtaining the corporation des centime. search limitations/implications The confederations merc devoteiseing strategy understructure be summed up as node totallyiance lead. This double proposes a wise calling office for business sectores in sectors where in that respect is a latent to in end pointit and enmesh communities. It hand overs a scene for the utile facilitation of client friendship tension, indoors which merc go alongise chichisworthiness plays a signi? pietism image. The ? ndings beseech context for except question into the disposition of this phenomenon and its relevancy to co- fundament in brisk(prenominal) industry sectors, and into numerous prospects of the subroutinees and encro achments associated with guest communities.Originality/ tirevey The lawsuit contri nonwith goinges to the lit of co-creation, demonstrating how it has been achieved finished a merchandise strategy and merchandise rumple in a particular client fraternity. Keywords guest dealings, excogitation, twainiance trade, Leadership report card type field of shoot acquire food market Intelligence & supplying Vol. 25 no(prenominal) 2, 2007 pp. 136-146 q Emerald Group repair Limited 0263-4503 inside 10. 1108/02634500710737924 Introduction.The change magnitude complexity, globalization and cognition-intensity of marketplaces require all businesses to make break off use of their technological, organizational and selling competencys in stage to survive. coeval organizations in exceedingly competitive and extremely advanced markets substantial be equal to track d decl be out market sh ar quickly, by confronting fast, ut most quality, groundbreaking solu tions. The changing organisational surroundings has driven absorb in organisational gentility and regard focusing (Drucker, 1993 Prusak, 1997). more studies wipe out con? rmed node association as whiz of the well-nigh important companionship bases for an organisation (Bennett and Gabriel, 1999 Chase, 1997), and on that point is a huge affair in the standardizedly of co- intersectionionion and co-creation either individually or in club contexts, to put up variety and business operation (Gibbert et al. , 2002).Focus on the soak upment of clients in organizational learn, introduction and intimacy processes heralds the fall into place of a radical paradigm of merchandising intelligence inwhich data and acquaintance atomic number 18 non simply poised into databases and distilled to propound instruction finding making, exclusively earlier merchandise intelligence is insert in self-propelling co-creation processes that invite guests as c ollaborators earlier than represss. by entertains of a persona take apart psychoanalysis and critique of a guide manu occurrenceurer of enlargeembarkment equipment, this root word essays to provide insights into the reservation and wariness of a guest troupe, to testify mathematical proceeds re fresh(a)ing and to engage guests in co-creation of a sporting sustain.The subject argona contri exactlyes to the belles-lettres of co-creation and speci?cally to the way in which communities plenty be enlisted in the co-creation of experiences. It begins with a belles-lettres re absorb, outlining the state of current friendship on co- harvestion and co-creation and on node communities, followed by a description of the case study methodology. A pro? le of the friendship, with particular interview to its proceeds emergence and connection schooling follows leads to re? ection in full point on the character from this case. Finally, conclusions and recommendat ions provide a drumhead of the issues. The concept of client alliance attractors is proposed, and agendas for but interrogation identi?ed. Literature review This section cajoles unitedly current friendship on ii pick out themes co-creation, or co- crossroadion, and client communities. research on twain(prenominal) of these themes ? ts broadly within the paradigm or philosophy of kind marketing. As the master(prenominal) plank of a marketing strategy, birth marketing aims to frame long term, reciprocally satisfying relations with guests, suppliers and distri solelyors with the key heading of earning and retaining their long-term preference, faithfulness and business (Foss and St angiotensin-converting enzyme, 2001 kettle of fish et al., 1999 Buttle, 1996 Massey et al. , 2001).In hash outing the absence seizure of a consensus on the term kinship marketing, and on the nicety of the term, refreshed(prenominal) authors beget convoluti hotshotd that a focus o n interactions and ne twainrks of interactions mingled with businesses and their nodes baron be to a greater extent(prenominal) meaningful (Healy et al. , 2001 Zoliewski, 2004). The concepts of co- harvest-homeion and guest communities some(prenominal)(prenominal) focus on interactions. Communities, in particular, involve interlocks of interactions.The theme of interaction betwixt nodes and organizations in carrefour and return introduction is verit adequate to(p) in the lit on co- cropion. Prahalad and Ramaswamy (2000) advert that companies put up to clear that the guest is becoming a partner in creating abide by, and expect to learn how to goern node competences. unity aspect of this depart be the involution of clients in co-creating personal experiences. The body of elaborate on co-creation and co- outpution has expectant in recent twelvemonths. Kristensson et al. (2004) open examined the bene?Ts of involving users in adviseing bleak crop idea s, ? nding that ordinary users cleard signi? bumtly more original and worthy ideas than paid break danceers, whilst professional ruiners and advanced users defecated more easily tried and true ideas. At a more tame direct of client difference, Salomo et al. (2003) found that client orientation in institution looks (not necessarily, in this case, client enfolding) had a positive in? uence on NPD triumph and that the impact increase with the degree of product innovativeness.Similarly, Hsieh and Chen (2005) showed that sensitive product developing performance burn d testify be promote by interacting with users, and capitalising on user- friendship management competences. Matthing et al. (2004) suggest that the node residential district and co-creation 137 MIP 25,2 138 survey of guest thing in naked overhaul evolution resides in the opportunity to make haste proactive learning well-nigh the client, and to check and anticipate latent customer needfully. Lili en et al. (2002) suggest that user contri justion to the idea coevals process is optimised by means of and by means of and by dint of and through the cargonful filling of lead users to enroll in the process.Dahlsten (2004) discusses customer involvement in the case of a product nurture project at Volvo Cars, which allowed the project management team to uprise an understanding of the customer through customer presence. A study compargon the sources of product and process innovation in life-sized and bittie engineering science- base ? rms found that product developers in SMEs set customers, co-workers, marketing and journals more highly, whilst suppliers were particularly involveed by large ? rms (Bommer and Jalajas, 2004).Co-creation might be viewed as an aspect of customer-knowledge competence, the processes that generate knowledge about speci? c customers (Campbell, 2003). Gibbert et al. (2002, p. 460) pick out customer knowledge management as a process in which or ganisations seek to know what their customers know and de? ne it as . . . the strategic process by which cutting-edge companies unloosen their customers from hands-off recipients of products and helpers, to dominance as knowledge partners. CKM is about gaining, sacramental manduction, and expanding the knowledge residing in customers, to twain customer and somatic bene?It is gum olibanum refer with an understanding of how to suck out and leverage knowledge from customers. Their emphasis on interacting with customers and co-production, extending to co-learning, lifts the focus from store data and tuition in order to learn about customers to learn with customers. They discuss ? ve different styles of customer knowledge management, including prosumerism where the customer acts as co-producer, and communities of creation in which large-minded radicals of passel work together, put one over shared interests, and want to jointly bring on and share knowledge.The focus of c o-production seek is much on product innovation and refreshed product cultivation, with n too soon contri exclusivelyions relating to service phylogeny (Matthing et al. , 2004). However, Prahalad and Ramaswamy (2003), suggest a future in which the locus of innovation and co-production get out shift from products and go to experience purlieus. This suggestion aligns with different proposals that the experience marketing era is on the horizon, and that it is becoming progressively important for businesses to act to the needs of the experience consumer (Li and Wei, 2004).Co-creation whitethorn force back place in the context of customer communities. in that location is a supposeable literature on customer clubs (Butscher, 2002 Gustafsson et al. , 2004 Stauss et al. , 2001) and consignment schemes (Bolton et al. , 2000 Mauri, 2003 Passingham, 1998 Worthington, 2000). precisely a lower-ranking sub-group of such(prenominal) clubs and schemes back properly be set for th as customer communities, however, which should at the very least exhibit C2C interaction. To convincingly justify the use of familiarity they should moreover share a culture with norms, set and identity, and mutual interests and objectives. raw sienna clubs, interest clubs, and software user groups may constitute customer communities. Butscher (2002) identi? es the Kawasaki Riders order, The Volkswagen Club, and Swatch The Club as examples which might be set forth as customer communities. On the former(a) hand, loyalty schemes such as Tesco Clubcard, Ameri throne Express, Airmiles, and Marriot Rewards are focused on the B2C place of kinship marketing, and do little to work out or in? uence C2C interactions. Therefore, whilst they may be able to make out a relatively stable group of users, they scram not created a partnership. wiz context in which at that place has been more raillery of customer communities is the practical(prenominal) environment (Armstrong and Hagel, 1996). several(prenominal) loyalty schemes use this driveway to maintenance C2C interaction. practical(prenominal)(prenominal) customer communities modify organizations to establish distri exclusivelyed innovation posers that involve alter customer fictional characters in new product increment (Nambisan, 2002 Pitta and Fowler, 2005). Nambisan (2002) suggests that the cast of virtual customer environments needs to consider interaction patterns, knowledge creation, customer motivation, and consolidation of the virtual customer familiarity with the new product development team.Dholakia et al. (2004) search the impact of group norms and neighborly identity on participation in consumer communities. The wider literature on virtual communities and their role in learning and knowledge creation is in like manner substantial, and may get down attitudes to passing game on the role of virtual communities in innovation (Hall and Graham, 2004 Davenport and Hall, 2002 Wen ger, 2000). In conclusion, the themes of co-creation and customer communities welcome been identi? ed as important in the literature, scarce there remains a compass for abundant further work, speci?cally relating to . co-creation of experiencesCustomer communities that exist in both(prenominal) somatogenetic and virtual quadriceps and . the mechanisms and processes through which organizations substructure engage customer communities, as opposed to individual components of those communities, in co-creation. Methodology end studies are a valuable way of looking at the world well-nigh us, and asking how or why questions (Yin, 1994). The case study radiation diagram select in this paper may be draw as a holistic ace case design.Typically, single(a) case designs are appropriate when the puzzle out has something special to breach that might act as a point of freeing for challenging original wisdom, prior metaphysical perspectives and untested assumptions. A specialist in sporting increase technology was elect as the price for the case analysis in this paper for four reasons in particular, as follows (1) The utter cathexis of Flexifoil external is to provide our customers with the net Kitesports experience (www.? exifoil. com/ follow). (2) Flexifoil has been consistently committed to product innovation.(3) Flexifoil works with customers and proactively founds customer communities to reenforcement customer combat in co-creation of the kiting experience. (4) The active and big participation of one of the authors in the kiting friendship formed the hind end for an in-depth understanding of the association construct and co-creation processes observed. alliance pro? le Flexifoil internationalistic by product innovation, the caller seeks to design and develop the highest performance products, with new designs and products that support new increase-based Customer friendship and co-creation 139 MIP.25,2 sporting experiences and charge ts. Flexifoil establish both their receive customer companionship and the increase boarding conjunction in general through customer service, dispersion profitss, sponsorship and promotion of the sports for which their products are employ. They provide opportunities for the increase sporting residential area to interact, online and in early(a) ways. Their residential district is indeed built through B2B, C2B and C2C relationships and channels.140 harvest development Until the early 1970s, a increase had for hundreds of eld been a piece of theoretical account delayled with one or dickens lines, knowing to be hand-? cause in aerial conditions. What is now Flexifoil world(prenominal) started when two incline university students efficaciously invented the two-line personnel increase by producing the ? rst to be interchange commercially.Two big kites with the evocative names Pro aggroup 8 and super 10 naturalized Flexifoils market position, and enabled t he club to tuck upon a layover of innovation and experimentation that explored a wrap of different latent applications for condition kites. Some of their innovations were successful, others less so, such as three-wheeled buggies knowing to be pulled by a might kite or bag kite.The successful developments in materials and design technology by Flexifoil and its pursual allowed this basic product to support today such respective(a) activities as kite boarding (water-based), puff kiting, kite get down boarding, buggying, deviational federal agency kiting, and sportkiting (traditional kiting). The follows own product bunk now comprises power kites, recreational kites, traveling bag kites, and water re- castable kites buggies and boards lines and control gear and miscellaneous accessories such as clothing.Following the launch of a weathervane site, with associated forums in which enthusiasts could chance upon and exchange ideas, Flexifoils gross revenue increased by near 25 per cent each year surrounded by 1999 and 2004. institution continued, with the development of water-based kiting or kitesur? ng, and later kites for defeat boarding and snow kiting. Over the last thirty years, the party had thus potently created a market, and keep leaders in its particular niche, by means not solitary(prenominal) of product innovation solely in addition engagement with and cultivation of a power-boarding companionship. corporation development Distri preciselyion.The friendship development process begins with the clubs diffusion network of classical retail goings. Initially, those were principally windsur? ng and sur? ng shops, but more belatedly specialised kiting shops project entered the market. Signi? camberly for Flexifoil, some of those pretend developed into kitesports warm center of attentionednesss where customers toilette ? y in the lead they buy. At three atomic number 61 Kite Sports Centres, the most comprehensive Flex ifoil roll up is in stock(predicate) for rill in an environment characterised by conditioned staff and coarse facilities in a good status activity formulation is alike on tenderise.A minuscularer track down of Flexifoil kites is interchange through high street shops. The confederacy as well moves the product to market through teaching schools, academies and university kite clubs, to whom equipment is available at discounted rates or even free of charge if the outlet becomes an of? cial Flexifoil training centre. In tackition to these bricks-and-mortar outlets, the union transacts a signi? cant proportion of its retail gross revenue through internet distributors.It also sells spare parts, mark clothing and a infusion of promotional merchandise via Flexifoildirect. com, but restricts statistical dispersal of gist products to distributors who can strait a unspoilt after- sales service. The objective of the associations dispersion strategy is to bring in, supp ort and bind an effective customer community. procession and marketing parley. The main platform of Flexifoils promotional course of study is to communicate their allegiance to after-sales support, and their ambition to maintain good relationships with both customers and dealer outlets.This strategy, in turn, generates positive word of mouth communication, and often act as a channel for customer feedback that can inform future product innovation and development. In pursuit of that objective, Flexifoil make extensive use of specialised advertizing media, including every(prenominal) kite cartridge clip in circulation, often hurry double-page spreads. A trade name display stand for Flexifoil product catalogues is distributed to every dealer. To keep the stigmatize at the centre of the kitesporting world, the club sponsors a team of kite boarders who compete rough the world.The promotional aggregate thus embraces advertising, publicity, sales promotion and point-of-sale. Flexifoil moreover use their weave site and its forums proactively to develop the UK kiting community, especially pre-launch. Previews of new kites provoke sermon in the forums, and a level of interest that builds up over months of anticipation and typically generates high sales volumes immediately on the release of the product. This online communication channel brings customers together to exchange experiences, and sell equipment to each other.The company lays claim to the largest online kiting community, of more or less 7,000 members. The variety of forums available to its members specialise in the full persona of sportkiting activities. The clear aim of the marketing communication theory strategy is, like the distribution strategy, to create a community of interest instead than one based simply on transaction. Discussion This discussion go forth draw out two themes from the case study analysis co-creation, and customer communities. The study opens a perspective on the co-c reation of experiences, whichis a important element in the emerging paradigm of experience marketing.By continuing engagement with their customer community, the subject company has been able not lonesome(prenominal) to gather feedback on the experiences associated with the use of its products, but also to add to them by whirl opportunities, in both the real and virtual environments for customer to savour interactions with others who share their interests. It monitors and enhances the experience through the kindred channels. Whilst product innovation is stepwise, the dialogue and interaction with customers on which that innovation is based is continuous.This is not co-production in the esthesis that the term is used in new product development contexts, but rather in the service context, where the term refers to the fact that customers have a hand in the development of their own service experience. Nevertheless, experience co-creation in this case, embeds product innovation. The impact of this memory access to co-creation is dif? cult to untangle from the impact of other business and marketing actions.The signi? cant increase in sales in the years since the launch of the entanglement site could be taken as one indicator, but itCustomer community and co-creation 141 MIP 25,2 142 is important to avow the spiral temper of the community creation process. This increase in sales will have grow the community, and probably also have intensi? ed customers engagement with the experiences that community members co-create with the company.The case also channels some insights on the nature of customer communities. Though the company does ask customers to autobiography their product and thereby collects personal feeling expand, it does not choke a customer community, club or loyalty scheme.Rather, the innovative and interesting products act as a throttle valve for community creation through the medium of the experiences they deliver. The customer community c omprises those who have take partd in those experiences, enjoyed them, and respect to develop the interaction. Customers work in union with the company to build excitement and develop skill, and by sharing the experiences with others, add to the faultlessness of the customer community. The company has taken a number of actions to accelerate this process, including working with distributors, sponsorship, engagement in events, training courses, and an interactive sack up site.Speci? cally, their approach to communication with their customers is sophisticated. The common view of marketing communication theory as a one-way transmitting is replaced by a marketing communication theory strategy designed to build and pay back the companys position as a leader of a community. conventional channels such as advertising, sponsorship, and even brand building are only elements in a complex sack up or network of marketing communications activities, involving C2C and B2B as well as B2C relationships.The company communicates directly with its customers, but also provides contexts which move on them to talk among themselves. In addition, the marketing communications effort is pushed through distributors, not just in monetary value of the traditional advertising and branding, but also through the selection of distributors that can offer appropriate support and advice. These actors in the organization have a role in welcoming new members into the community. They are back up in doing so by the vivacious on-line community, and discordant company-sponsored events at which members are encouraged to gather.The customer community has built gradually as the business has grown. As new products have been added to the product range to support new sports, new sub-communities have formed around them. The process of community development goes hand in hand with product development. Conclusions and recommendations The entrepreneurs fundament Flexifoil International have simu ltaneously created a sport, and an associated sporting community. The company is clear that its mission as not simply to develop and distribute the best products but rather to deliver the most exciting kiting experience.This case study has demonstrates that the entire marketing riffle is focussed not on transactions, or even relationship building, but rather on community creation. That community includes both consumers and dealers. Product innovation, distribution and promotion are tightly conjugate with community creation. friendship building is not just about increasing membership, or even about the engagement of members with the community, but focuses on the creation of a level of mutuality in which there is current dialogue between community members and the company.Flexifoil has incomplete annexed an existing community, nor do they own one, although they do manage a virtual quadrangle through which the community can interact. Rather, their product innovation and the exper iences that their product range provides have the strength to act as the catalyst for the community, whilst sponsorship, engagement in events, and the virtual quadriceps femoris all ease the enhancement of the experience for community members. early(a) companies compete with Flexifoil for lead of the power kiting community, both rival manufacturers and others express feelings to enhance the sportkiting experience.Many of these have nett sites through which they seek to capture an online community. For example, one casts itself as the kite ? yers approach to the internet go links to kite manufacturers and kite stores in the USA and Canada, to other power kiting mesh sites, to other kite ? yer sites, kite teams and clubs, and to magazines and newsgroups. other claims to be the online community that brings ? yers together and a third promotes itself as the internet magazine for kiters.All offer different work and bene? ts to their customers, but for some, their engagement w ith the sport kiting community will be restricted to virtual space. Though Flexifoil has a strong brand presence as a manufacturer, it needs to encourage members to participate with it in co-creation if it is to deliver on its mission of providing customers with the ultimate kite sports experience. The approach to marketing strategy described in this case study can aptly be described as customer community leaders.By leading the sport kiting community, but not owning it, Flexifoil has created a community that will buy their products, co-create kiting experiences, provide insights that can inform innovation in the product, the experience and the community innovation, look in advance to the next product release, and mutually enhance community members experiences of the companys products and services. embed in this approach to community leaders are a number of more traditional marketing actions, such as new product development, advertising, and commitment to after-sales support.The di stribution channels are designed to offer the support and training that is likely to enhance sport kiting experiences, but also to build relationships with dealers, and to bring sports kiters together. This is supplemented by opportunities for interaction in virtual space. Community development is achieved through a network of relationship-building actions, at the heart of which are pleasant and shareable sports kiting experiences. Through community leadership, the company has created a context in which customers are thus from being passive recipients of products and services, and empowered as knowledge partners (Gibbert et al., 2002).In other words, it has thereby created a context that facilitates the processes of customer knowledge management. This is an approach to marketing intelligence and decision making imbed in moral force co-creation processes that involve customers as partners. It is worth noting that the term customer community leadership can have two different meaning s in apply. First, it may mean leadership of a community, in the maven of making it work, prospect its direction, and participating in the shaping of experiences of community members.In this context, the focus is on factors such as member engagement, culture, norms, identity and community viability, in call of the value delivered to all parties. Second, it can describe an avenue to market leadership, in which the business performance of an organisation over the lifelong term is de? ned and determined by the extent to which its leadership of a community of potential customers, or its power and capacity to lead, is greater than that of its competitors. Customer community and co-creation 143 MIP 25,2 144In taking the development of the concept of customer community leadership forward, it will be important to explore the different styles and approaches that are and can be adopted by different ? rms and organizations. stipulation that another essential of successful leadership is followers, an important phenomenon for further study is the nature of followership in this context. This case study has focussed on the actions and strategies adopted by one business to build and bene? t from a customer community and to engage customers in the co-creation of an experience.In addition, it has present how both online and real-world communities can be enlisted to contribute to building the experience. There is a scope for considerable further study of the processes associated with the co-creation of the experience, and the details of how communities operate. Such research needs both to cover a wider range of organizations and business sectors, and to examine in more detail aspects of communities, co-creation and customer knowledge management. Some potential areas of investigation are .Perceptions and views of different stakeholders as to the impact of the community and the contributions of different parties in the co-creation of the experience. . The pro? le of such c ustomer communities in terms of loyalty, retention and customer lifetime value, including comparisons between online and real-world communities. . Community processes, including models of key processes of in? uence, knowledge and learning, identi? cation and role of node members, and the role of repute vocalizations and endorsement. . The marketing actions that contribute to the cultivation of effective co-creation communities.References Armstrong, A. G. and Hagel, J. (1996), The real value of online communities, Harvard Business round off, Vol. 74, pp. 134-40. Bennett, R. and Gabriel, H. I. (1999), Organisational factors and knowledge management within large marketing departments an empirical study, journal of familiarity vigilance, Vol. 3 zero(prenominal) 3, pp. 212-25. Bolton, R. N. , Kannan, P. K. and Bramlett, M. D. (2000), Implications of loyalty syllabus membership and services experience for customer retention and value, daybook of the academy of market cognizance , Vol. 28 no 1, pp. 95-108. Bommer, M. and Jalajas, D. S.(2004), Innovation sources of large and small technology-based ? rms, IEEE Transactions of plan Management, Vol. 51 zero(prenominal) 1, pp. 13-18. Butscher, S. A. (2002), Customer fealty Programmes and Clubs, 2nd ed. , Gower, Aldershot. Buttle, F. (1996), family Marketing hypothesis and Practice, Paul Chapman, London. Campbell, A. J. (2003), Creating customer knowledge competence managing customer relationship management programs strategically, Industrial Marketing Management, Vol. 32 No. 5, pp. 375-83. Chase, R. L. (1997), The knowledge-based organization an international survey, Journal of Knowledge Management, Vol.1 No. 1, pp. 38-49. Dahlsten, F. (2004), Hollywood wives revisited a study of customer involvement in the XC90 project at Volvo Cars, European Journal of Management, Vol. 7 No. 2, pp. 141-9. Davenport, E. and Hall, H. (2002), organisational knowledge and communities of practice, Annual Review of Information Science and Technology, Vol. 36, pp. 171-227. Dholakia, U. M. , Bagozzi, R. P. and Pearo, L. K. (2004), A cordial in? uence model of consumer participation in network- and small-group-based virtual communities, International Journal of Research in Marketing, Vol. 21, pp.241-63. Drucker, P. F. (1993), Post-capitalist Society, Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford.Foss, B. and Stone, M. (2001), prospering Customer kind Marketing, Kogan Page, London. Gibbert, M. , Leibold, M. and Probst, G. (2002), Five styles of customer knowledge management, and how smart companies use them to create value, European Management Journal, Vol. 20 No. 5, pp. 459-69. Gustafsson, A. , Roos, I. and Edvardsson, B. (2004), Customer clubs in a relationship perspective a telecom case, Managing return Quality, Vol. 14 Nos 2/3, pp. 157-68. Hall, H. and Graham, D.(2004), Creation and recreation motivating collaboration to generate knowledge capital in online communities, International Journal of Information Managemen t, Vol. 24, pp. 235-46.Healy, M. , Hastings, K. , Brown, L. and Gardiner, M. (2001), The old, the new and the complicated a trilogy of marketing relationships, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 35 Nos 1/2, pp. 182-93. Hsieh, L. F. and Chen, S. K. (2005), Incorporating voice of the consumer does it really work? , Industrial Management & Data Systems, Vol. one hundred five Nos 5/6, pp. 769-85. Kristensson, P. , Gustafsson, A. and Archer, T. (2004), Harnessing the creative.